From the Monson team
Practical insurance know-how for Utah families and businesses.
Proven Ways to Save on Car Insurance Even If You're a Safe Driver
Car insurance costs keep climbing — the average driver now pays close to $2,700 a year, per Consumer Reports — but a meaningful share of that is reducible. The piece linked above walks through how, and most of it is exactly the work an independent brokerage already does for its clients.
The core money-saving moves Consumer Reports highlights:
- Comparison shopping across carriers. Premiums for the same coverage vary widely; rates also drift up if you stay with one carrier for years without re-shopping.
- Claiming every available discount. Safe-driver, multi-car, paperless billing, defensive-driver courses, low annual mileage, professional/alumni associations — many drivers leave several of these unclaimed.
- Bundling home and auto. Carrier-dependent, but often 5–25%.
- Raising deductibles sensibly. Moving from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible commonly saves 10–15%; only worth it if you have the cushion to absorb the higher out-of-pocket on a claim.
- Dropping collision and comprehensive on older cars. Consumer Reports’ rule of thumb: when that coverage costs more than ~10% of the car’s value, the math no longer makes sense.
- Updating the insurer after life changes. Removing a teen driver from the policy after they move out can save up to $2,000 a year alone. Same for fewer commute miles, a paid-off car, or a relocation.
- Avoiding small claims that trigger surcharges — sometimes paying a small repair out of pocket is cheaper than the multi-year premium increase a claim triggers.
The brokerage tie-in is that nearly every one of those comes down to comparing carriers, knowing each company’s discount menu, and right-sizing coverage — which is exactly the work an independent broker does on your behalf, every renewal, with carriers you’d otherwise have to call one by one. A captive single-company agent only has one menu to offer; we have thirty.
If you haven’t had your auto policy re-shopped in a couple of years, it’s almost certainly costing you something. We’re happy to do it.